At the end of the latest Game of Thrones episode, we watched in shock as a bloodied Arya Stark stumbled through the streets of Braavos, helpless and terrified. She had just been stabbed by the Waif after the faceless girl disguised herself as an old woman, before launching a brutal attack on Arya, plunging a knife into her stomach.

In a panic, Arya managed to escape her clutches enough to jump over the side of the bridge and stayed underwater so the Waif would think she was dead. She then emerged in a pool of blood before wobbling through the markets in Braavos, attracting suspicious glances from not-so-friendly onlookers.

On first watch, it was clear that Arya was in deep trouble. However, many fans believe that the scene was not as it seemed. In fact, in a theory that supports Arya’s claim to being the biggest badass in Westeros, fans are purporting that it was all an elaborate ruse from the Stark girl and that wasn’t even her who the Waif stabbed.

Arya’s elaborate ruse


What? Yes, we know it sounds as crazy as the Mad King screaming ‘burn them all,’ but hear this out…

“We are led to believe Arya got stabbed, however there are some problems with what happened this episode,” Reddit user iPlayNL noted.

“First off, Arya seemed different from the start. Her scene with the merchant, her walk all seemed very confident, which is unusual after the events this season. Also, where did she get the money from? Why was she not carrying Needle [her sword] with her? How come after all she knew about the faceless man she just stood there on a bridge not paying any attention?”

Intriguing indeed. If you think about it, Arya’s behaviour doesn’t quite add up leading up to the scene where the Waif attacks her. The only thing that adds up is that the Waif beats her, because she’s been doing that all season.

“We can assume she knows enough from training to figure the waif will attack to the body,” passingwisdom added.

“So I believe she has 1 or more pigs blood pouches around her body. She knows where and how to do this because last episode… she saved the actress. The actress then provided her help to make the scene on the bridge large and realistic. … She then leaves the water and leaves a trail of blood…. to lead her [enemies] to her. Expecting an unarmed (because she choose not to show needle during the fight scene) and injured girl; they will instead walk down a dark alley and be met with an uninjured girl who knows how to fight in the dark and carrying a sword.”

Jaqen was disguised as Arya


While that theory is very convincing, others have went as far as to say Arya on the bridge was actually Jaqen H’ghar disguised as her, which really puts an insane twist on proceedings.

“That wasn’t [A]rya. She would have been carrying needle,” froschkonig argued. “She wasn’t aware that [Jaqen] said not to make her suffer, so making a big show of her suffering doesn’t make sense. It was [Jaqen] testing the waif, and by stabbing her in the stomach and not just slashing the throat, she disobeyed orders just like arya did. [Jaqen] is gonna lay some faceless justice down.”

If we were to choose, we’d love the latter to come true. We’d love to see the Waif get what’s coming to her. Also, it would be great if Jaqen actually did something for a change as opposed to roaming the halls of the House of Black and White.

But the theory that takes the biscuit: Arya and the Waif are the same person

Wow – these theories keep getting more and more insane. This last one really goes deep into the psyche of Arya and we almost think it’s a bit too sophisticated for Thrones, as much as we like it. We’d love to hear what you think though: do you think Arya is Jaqen, or Arya is the Waif, or something completely different? For quite a while, we felt as though the whole Braavos/Faceless Men storyline treaded water – but it’s exploded spectacularly now and we can’t wait to see how it pans out in the climactic season 6 episodes.